Don't Think for Yourself: Authority and Belief in Medieval Philosophy

Peter Adamson
Paperback, 194 pages
9780268203405

How do we judge whether we should be willing to follow the views of experts or whether we ought to try to come to our own, independent views? This book seeks the answer in medieval philosophical thought.

In this engaging study into the history of philosophy and epistemology, Peter Adamson provides an answer to a question as relevant today as it was in the medieval period: how and when should we turn to the authoritative expertise of other people in forming our own beliefs? He challenges us to reconsider our approach to this question through a constructive recovery of the intellectual and cultural traditions of the Islamic world, the Byzantine Empire, and Latin Christendom.

Adamson begins by foregrounding the distinction in Islamic philosophy between taqlīd, or the uncritical acceptance of authority, and ijtihād, or judgment based on independent effort, the latter of which was particularly prized in Islamic law, theology, and philosophy during the medieval period. He then demonstrates how the Islamic tradition paves the way for the development of what he calls a “justified taqlīd,” according to which one develops the skills necessary to critically and selectively follow an authority based on their reliability. The book proceeds to reconfigure our understanding of the relation between authority and independent thought in the medieval world by illuminating how women found spaces to assert their own intellectual authority, how medieval writers evaluated the authoritative status of Plato and Aristotle, and how independent reasoning was deployed to defend one Abrahamic faith against the other.

Contents
1. Taqlīd: Authority and the Intellectual Elite in the Islamic World
2. Too High a Standard: Knowledge and Skepticism in Medieval Philosophy
3. Testing the Prophets: Reason and the Choice of Faiths
4. Using the Pagans: Reason in Interreligious Debate
5. Some Pagans are Better than Others: the Merits of Plato and Aristotle
6. Finding Their Voices: Women in Byzantine and Latin Christian Philosophy